Protect our Mangrove in Trinidad and Tobago


A little bombshell
September 12, 2008, 8:54 am
Filed under: activism

Below is a little bombshell sent by Rhea…


Tonight I am going to play an ace or let the proverbial cat out of the bag.

THE WORDS OF A FORMER PROJECT MANAGER OF THE ESSAR STEEL GROUP(TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO). HE WAS RESPONDING TO QUESTIONS I ASKED HIM.

Without meaning to detract you from your commendable efforts to keep Trinidad (a country and people, that my family and I grew to love, during our stay there) clean and pure, I would like to say the following about Essar:

1. I am not aware of any Essar operation in Brazil. This may be checked by going to their website www.essar.com. There is then a further link that takes you to Essar Steel. A full list of their operations worldwide would be available there.

2. They have an operation in Indonesia, which is relatively environmentally benign, as it is a cold rolling mill that merely re-rolls thicker steel bands into thin sheets.
(For pollution, you are probably referring to the——, who have large operations both in Indonesia and Brazil).

3. The Ruias of Essar are a different breed of young Indian entrepreneurs, with a wide vision, dynamism and a large-heartedness, hard to find in businessmen. They have generally taken excellent care of their workers and the communities around them. They have an impeccable record in India.

4. Having worked for both of them, I can assure you that Essar are completely unlike the more rapacious —– of ——, down the road at Point Lisas, who have paid scant regard to the environment/communities in Trinidad. Frankly, I feel quite ashamed, as a Person of Indian Origin, to see the devastation wrought by the ——. They have taken much from, but given little back to Trinidad.

5. It would be unfair to blame Essar for the proposed site. It was given to them by NEC and the Trinidad Government. Essar had no choice. It was a “fait accompli”, so to speak.

6. Personally, I would have preferred a site to the north of the Point Lisas Industrial Estate- north of the port and the big power plant (PowerGen or is it Tringen, I forget)- towards the Waterloo direction . This location was further from human habitation and less mangrove would have been destroyed.

7. I do feel the concern of the communities of Pranz Gardens, Claxton Bay, California, Savonella estate and others around, but I also feel deeply saddened about the hostility and antagonism towards Essar.

8.Coming as they do from a humble background, I sincerely feel that the Ruia brothers will go to great lengths to meet the concerns of the locals around them.

9. As I had said in a speech, over two years ago, before your Honorable Prime Minister, that Essar will surely strive to make the venture as much as possible—-

“A project by the Trinidadians, for the Trinidadians and of the Trinidadians”

I hope I have answered your doubts. Please feel free to ask any more questions.

With best wishes and all success in your efforts to keep your country clean.

THIS MAN SIGNED MY ONLINE PETITION. THIS MAN WAS THE PROJECT MANAGER FOR ESSAR STEEL IN TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO AND HE SIGNED MY PETITION. DOESN’T THAT SAY SOMETHING? THIS MAN IS NOT A TRINIDADIAN.


3 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Hello, I’m an employee of Essar in Sault Ste Marie, Canada. You can find us listed on the Essar website under the link provided. Essar just bought our company last year and I’m sorry to say that I don’t agree with any of the comments made about the type of employer Essar has been. The problems we had before Essar took over have not gotten better. In my opinion things have gotten worse and appear to be getting worse.

Yes, they have started expanding the business and building and growing the company. But that is the only positive I can say. I have not seen the large-heartedness mentioned above.

I also want to comment on what a wonderfull country Trinidad and Tobago is. I visited the islands when I was in high school and spent my vacation at the Radison Crown Hotel (don’t know if it is still there) on the island of Tobago.

Comment by Mark

Dear Mark,

I am part of The Resource Protection Group. These are not my words. They are the words of the last Project Manager of Essar Steel Trinidad and Tobago. Please read the article in its entirety. I could not have taken parts of his letter out it would have been unethical. This gentleman signed our petition against the proposed Essar Steel Mill and its associated port in Trinidad and Tobago.

I have over one hundred and fifty postings regarding Essar Steel Group on this Greenpeace Forum alone dealing with the horror that Essar Steel is about to unleash on my country. I saw your name on my petition and actually I was speaking about you, with Dr. Wayne Kublalsingh about thirty minutes ago. Please sir we would like to contact you.
Please find a list of our links. We are the “Resource Protection Group”. Please join us in this fight to preserve our environment. elp us to spread the word in Canada, a country I went I once lived in and grew to love.Unfortunately,while I lived in Ontario I never the pleasure of visiting Sault Ste Marie. I used to live in the Atlantic Provinces.The very picturesque and unspoilt beauty of the Canadian east coast and truly a marvel to behold.

1. Circulate our petition
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/petition/957999809

2. Catch me on greenpeace.org
forum.greenpeace.org/int/showthread.php?t=583 2&page=6

One link and you can find the rest of threads by clicking on my photo.

3.Comment and add photos to our blog at
claxtonbaymangrove.wordpress.com/

4. We are on YouTube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rue1HjHdBmA

5. Our Flickr Groups

http://www.flickr.com/groups/claxtonbaymangrove/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/29102645@N06/

I have posting all over the web. Please check our Blog.

Regards,
Ms.Rhea Ranu Mungal
Resource Protection Group
Trinidad and Tobago
rhea.mungal@yahoo.com
868-769-4672

Dr. Wayne Kublalsingh
868-771-5181

Comment by Rhea Mungal

The site must not be built whatsoever. Being sorry for our people is not enough. There are larger questions also such as subsidies and cheap gas at next to nothing, with of course, you know… those private slippery closed door handshakes. We are simple people, but we are awakening.

Comment by gary aboud




Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>